Skip to Content

Find Comparable ETFs for Vanguard ESG U.S. Stock ETF

Vanguard ESG U.S. Stock ETF

ESGV - BTS
ETF Category
Large Cap Growth Equities
Asset Class
Equity
AUM
$9,046M
Expense Ratio
0.09% (Low)
Trading Volume
223.3K (Moderate)
Issuer
Vanguard
Number of Holdings
1428
Inception Date
2018-09-18 (6 years)
Momentum
Very Weak Neutral Very Strong
AUM
Micro Medium Very Large
Concentration
Very Low Very High Very High
Volatility
Very Low Moderate Very High
Overview
Momentum
Concentration
ESG
P/E Ratio
21.00
Annual Dividend Rate
1.18%
Beta
1.03
50-Day Moving Average
$106.72
Price vs. 50-Day MA
-3.05%
200-Day Moving Average
$101.58
Price vs. 200-Day MA
1.85%
1 Year Fund Flow
$601M (7% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
$2,700M (30% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$5,842M (65% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings (Market Cap Weighted)
35.76%
% in Top 15 Holdings (Market Cap Weighted)
41.02%
% in Top 50 Holdings (Market Cap Weighted)
57.89%
ESG Score
6.7000
ESG Peer %
49.57
ESG Global %
57.30
Carbon Intensity (Tons CO2e/$M Sales)
41
ESG Exclusion %
4.74
Sustainable Impact %
8.60

iShares MSCI USA ESG Select ETF

SUSA - PCX
View SUSA's Comps
A+
TaxGhost's "TG Grade" is calculated from 100+ datapoints including fundamental metrics, factors, country, correlation, sub-sector, and more.
Large Cap Growth Equities
Equity
AUM: $3,566M
Expense Ratio: 0.25% (Low)
Volume: 150.6K (Moderate)
Issuer: BlackRock, Inc.
Holdings: 176
Inception: 2005-01-24 (20 years)
Neutral Momentum
Medium AUM
Very High Concentration
Moderate Volatility
Compare
Overview
Momentum
Concent.
ESG

The iShares MSCI USA ESG Select ETF also focuses on U.S. equities with strong ESG ratings, making it a direct competitor to ESGV in the socially responsible investment space.

correlation
A+

correlation

Measures how closely the two assets' prices move together over time. A high correlation suggests similar market reactions and investor sentiment.

Pearson Correlation: 97%

R-squared: 93%

This indicates a strong positive relationship between the price movements of these assets.

network
A+

network

Evaluates the overlap in business networks, partnerships, and industry relationships, indicating similarity in market positioning and competitive landscape.

  • Common comparables: 7
  • ESGV in SUSA's comparables: No
  • SUSA in ESGV's comparables: Yes

A high score suggests the assets are often compared to each other and share many industry peers, indicating similar competitive environments and market perceptions.

valuation
A+

valuation

Compares valuation metrics to assess if the assets are valued similarly by the market, indicating comparable investor expectations and perceived growth potential.

  • P/E Ratio: 21.00 vs 21.87

A high score indicates that the market values these assets similarly relative to their financials, suggesting comparable growth expectations and risk profiles.

volatility
A+

volatility

Compares price volatility and risk profiles, indicating similarity in market behavior, risk, and potential for price swings.

  • ESGV Beta: 1.03 (Average)
  • SUSA Beta: 1.02 (Average)
  • ESGV 200-day Volatility: 12.89%
  • SUSA 200-day Volatility: 11.95%

A high score suggests both assets have similar sensitivity to market movements, implying comparable risk levels and potential for both gains and losses.

momentum
A+

momentum

Compares recent price momentum, showing similarity in short-term market performance and investor sentiment.

  • ESGV Price vs 200-day MA: 102%
  • SUSA Price vs 200-day MA: 103%

Performance Comparison:

Period ESGV SUSA
Year_1 20% 19%
Year_3 6% 6%
Year_5 14% 14%

A high score indicates both assets are experiencing similar price trends relative to their recent history, suggesting comparable market enthusiasm or concern.

geo
A+

geo

Evaluates the geographical similarity of the assets based on country, currency, and exchange.

  • Currency: USD vs USD
  • Exchange: BTS vs PCX

A high score indicates that both assets operate in similar geographical markets, facing comparable economic conditions, regulations, and market dynamics.

sector
A+

sector

Compares the sector, industry, and other classifications of both assets.

  • ETF Category: Large Cap Growth Equities vs Large Cap Growth Equities

A high score indicates that the assets operate in similar business areas, facing comparable market conditions, regulatory environments, and industry trends.

Partial matches are considered for more nuanced comparisons, allowing for a higher score even when classifications are not identical but closely related.

dividend
A+

dividend

Compares dividend policies, showing similarity in shareholder return strategies and income potential for investors.

  • ESGV Dividend Yield: 1%
  • SUSA Dividend Yield: 1%

A high score indicates similar approaches to returning capital to shareholders, suggesting comparable appeal to income-focused investors.

Select Mutual Comparables:

P/E Ratio
21.87
Annual Dividend Rate
1.21%
Beta
1.02
50-Day Moving Average
$123.65
Price vs. 50-Day MA
-1.18%
200-Day Moving Average
$118.60
Price vs. 200-Day MA
3.03%
1 Year Fund Flow
-$1,156M (-32% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
-$593M (-17% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$803M (23% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings
27%
% in Top 15 Holdings
33%
% in Top 50 Holdings
64%
ESG Score
8.3200
ESG Peer %
99.92
ESG Global %
99.22
Carbon Intensity
48
ESG Exclusion %
0.11
Sustainable Impact %
10.18

SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Growth ETF

SPYG - PCX
View SPYG's Comps
A+
TaxGhost's "TG Grade" is calculated from 100+ datapoints including fundamental metrics, factors, country, correlation, sub-sector, and more.
Large Cap Growth Equities
Equity
AUM: $27,961M
Expense Ratio: 0.04% (Very Low)
Volume: 2.3M (High)
Issuer: State Street
Holdings: 232
Inception: 2000-09-25 (24 years)
Neutral Momentum
Large AUM
Low Concentration
Moderate Volatility
Compare
Overview
Momentum
Concent.
ESG

The SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Growth ETF targets large-cap growth stocks like ESGV, aligning with similar investment themes and performance objectives.

correlation
A+

correlation

Measures how closely the two assets' prices move together over time. A high correlation suggests similar market reactions and investor sentiment.

Pearson Correlation: 95%

R-squared: 91%

This indicates a strong positive relationship between the price movements of these assets.

network
A+

network

Evaluates the overlap in business networks, partnerships, and industry relationships, indicating similarity in market positioning and competitive landscape.

  • Common comparables: 3
  • ESGV in SPYG's comparables: No
  • SPYG in ESGV's comparables: Yes

A high score suggests the assets are often compared to each other and share many industry peers, indicating similar competitive environments and market perceptions.

valuation
A+

valuation

Compares valuation metrics to assess if the assets are valued similarly by the market, indicating comparable investor expectations and perceived growth potential.

  • P/E Ratio: 21.00 vs 19.67

A high score indicates that the market values these assets similarly relative to their financials, suggesting comparable growth expectations and risk profiles.

volatility
A

volatility

Compares price volatility and risk profiles, indicating similarity in market behavior, risk, and potential for price swings.

  • ESGV Beta: 1.03 (Average)
  • SPYG Beta: 1.05 (Average)
  • ESGV 200-day Volatility: 12.89%
  • SPYG 200-day Volatility: 17.47%

A high score suggests both assets have similar sensitivity to market movements, implying comparable risk levels and potential for both gains and losses.

momentum
A+

momentum

Compares recent price momentum, showing similarity in short-term market performance and investor sentiment.

  • ESGV Price vs 200-day MA: 102%
  • SPYG Price vs 200-day MA: 105%

Performance Comparison:

Period ESGV SPYG
Year_1 20% 24%
Year_3 6% 6%
Year_5 14% 15%

A high score indicates both assets are experiencing similar price trends relative to their recent history, suggesting comparable market enthusiasm or concern.

geo
A+

geo

Evaluates the geographical similarity of the assets based on country, currency, and exchange.

  • Currency: USD vs USD
  • Exchange: BTS vs PCX

A high score indicates that both assets operate in similar geographical markets, facing comparable economic conditions, regulations, and market dynamics.

sector
A+

sector

Compares the sector, industry, and other classifications of both assets.

  • ETF Category: Large Cap Growth Equities vs Large Cap Growth Equities

A high score indicates that the assets operate in similar business areas, facing comparable market conditions, regulatory environments, and industry trends.

Partial matches are considered for more nuanced comparisons, allowing for a higher score even when classifications are not identical but closely related.

dividend
A+

dividend

Compares dividend policies, showing similarity in shareholder return strategies and income potential for investors.

  • ESGV Dividend Yield: 1%
  • SPYG Dividend Yield: 1%

A high score indicates similar approaches to returning capital to shareholders, suggesting comparable appeal to income-focused investors.

Select Mutual Comparables:

P/E Ratio
19.67
Annual Dividend Rate
0.79%
Beta
1.05
50-Day Moving Average
$89.86
Price vs. 50-Day MA
-2.53%
200-Day Moving Average
$83.55
Price vs. 200-Day MA
4.84%
1 Year Fund Flow
$3,796M (14% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
$8,959M (32% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$12,302M (44% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings
59%
% in Top 15 Holdings
64%
% in Top 50 Holdings
81%
ESG Score
6.8300
ESG Peer %
70.93
ESG Global %
63.03
Carbon Intensity
43
ESG Exclusion %
9.07
Sustainable Impact %
10.72

Nuveen ESG Large-Cap Growth ETF

NULG - BTS
View NULG's Comps
A+
TaxGhost's "TG Grade" is calculated from 100+ datapoints including fundamental metrics, factors, country, correlation, sub-sector, and more.
Large Cap Growth Equities
Equity
AUM: $1,444M
Expense Ratio: 0.26% (Low)
Volume: 84.2K (Low)
Issuer: TIAA Board of Governors
Holdings: 63
Inception: 2016-12-13 (8 years)
Weak Momentum
Medium AUM
Moderate Concentration
Moderate Volatility
Compare
Overview
Momentum
Concent.
ESG

The Nuveen ESG Large-Cap Growth ETF invests in large-cap growth stocks with an emphasis on ESG factors, making it a suitable alternative for ESGV investors.

correlation
A+

correlation

Measures how closely the two assets' prices move together over time. A high correlation suggests similar market reactions and investor sentiment.

Pearson Correlation: 94%

R-squared: 88%

This indicates a strong positive relationship between the price movements of these assets.

network
A+

network

Evaluates the overlap in business networks, partnerships, and industry relationships, indicating similarity in market positioning and competitive landscape.

  • Common comparables: 6
  • ESGV in NULG's comparables: No
  • NULG in ESGV's comparables: Yes

A high score suggests the assets are often compared to each other and share many industry peers, indicating similar competitive environments and market perceptions.

valuation
A

valuation

Compares valuation metrics to assess if the assets are valued similarly by the market, indicating comparable investor expectations and perceived growth potential.

  • P/E Ratio: 21.00 vs 33.94

A high score indicates that the market values these assets similarly relative to their financials, suggesting comparable growth expectations and risk profiles.

volatility
A

volatility

Compares price volatility and risk profiles, indicating similarity in market behavior, risk, and potential for price swings.

  • ESGV Beta: 1.03 (Average)
  • NULG Beta: 1.12 (Average)
  • ESGV 200-day Volatility: 12.89%
  • NULG 200-day Volatility: 16.62%

A high score suggests both assets have similar sensitivity to market movements, implying comparable risk levels and potential for both gains and losses.

momentum
A+

momentum

Compares recent price momentum, showing similarity in short-term market performance and investor sentiment.

  • ESGV Price vs 200-day MA: 102%
  • NULG Price vs 200-day MA: 100%

Performance Comparison:

Period ESGV NULG
Year_1 20% 22%
Year_3 6% 7%
Year_5 14% 17%

A high score indicates both assets are experiencing similar price trends relative to their recent history, suggesting comparable market enthusiasm or concern.

geo
A+

geo

Evaluates the geographical similarity of the assets based on country, currency, and exchange.

  • Currency: USD vs USD
  • Exchange: BTS vs BTS

A high score indicates that both assets operate in similar geographical markets, facing comparable economic conditions, regulations, and market dynamics.

sector
A+

sector

Compares the sector, industry, and other classifications of both assets.

  • ETF Category: Large Cap Growth Equities vs Large Cap Growth Equities

A high score indicates that the assets operate in similar business areas, facing comparable market conditions, regulatory environments, and industry trends.

Partial matches are considered for more nuanced comparisons, allowing for a higher score even when classifications are not identical but closely related.

dividend
A+

dividend

Compares dividend policies, showing similarity in shareholder return strategies and income potential for investors.

  • ESGV Dividend Yield: 1%
  • NULG Dividend Yield: 0%

A high score indicates similar approaches to returning capital to shareholders, suggesting comparable appeal to income-focused investors.

Select Mutual Comparables:

P/E Ratio
33.94
Annual Dividend Rate
0.39%
Beta
1.12
50-Day Moving Average
$87.06
Price vs. 50-Day MA
-4.04%
200-Day Moving Average
$83.43
Price vs. 200-Day MA
0.13%
1 Year Fund Flow
$44M (3% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
$372M (26% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$901M (62% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings
54%
% in Top 15 Holdings
63%
% in Top 50 Holdings
97%
ESG Score
7.7300
ESG Peer %
98.72
ESG Global %
92.96
Carbon Intensity
19
ESG Exclusion %
0.00
Sustainable Impact %
13.52

Vanguard International Dividend Appreciation Index Fund ETF Shares

VIGI - NGM
View VIGI's Comps
A
TaxGhost's "TG Grade" is calculated from 100+ datapoints including fundamental metrics, factors, country, correlation, sub-sector, and more.
Foreign Large Cap Equities
Equity
AUM: $7,039M
Expense Ratio: 0.10% (Low)
Volume: 96.5K (Low)
Issuer: Vanguard
Holdings: 338
Inception: 2016-02-25 (9 years)
Neutral Momentum
Medium AUM
Very High Concentration
Low Volatility
Compare
Overview
Momentum
Concent.
ESG

The Vanguard International Dividend Appreciation ETF offers a global perspective on ESG investing while still focusing on growth-oriented equities, appealing to investors seeking diversification.

correlation
A

correlation

Measures how closely the two assets' prices move together over time. A high correlation suggests similar market reactions and investor sentiment.

Pearson Correlation: 53%

R-squared: 28%

This indicates a moderate positive relationship between the price movements of these assets.

network
A

network

Evaluates the overlap in business networks, partnerships, and industry relationships, indicating similarity in market positioning and competitive landscape.

  • Common comparables: 0
  • ESGV in VIGI's comparables: No
  • VIGI in ESGV's comparables: Yes

A high score suggests the assets are often compared to each other and share many industry peers, indicating similar competitive environments and market perceptions.

valuation
A+

valuation

Compares valuation metrics to assess if the assets are valued similarly by the market, indicating comparable investor expectations and perceived growth potential.

  • P/E Ratio: 21.00 vs 20.60

A high score indicates that the market values these assets similarly relative to their financials, suggesting comparable growth expectations and risk profiles.

volatility
A

volatility

Compares price volatility and risk profiles, indicating similarity in market behavior, risk, and potential for price swings.

  • ESGV Beta: 1.03 (Average)
  • VIGI Beta: 0.77 (Low)
  • ESGV 200-day Volatility: 12.89%
  • VIGI 200-day Volatility: 11.10%

A high score suggests both assets have similar sensitivity to market movements, implying comparable risk levels and potential for both gains and losses.

momentum
A+

momentum

Compares recent price momentum, showing similarity in short-term market performance and investor sentiment.

  • ESGV Price vs 200-day MA: 102%
  • VIGI Price vs 200-day MA: 102%

Performance Comparison:

Period ESGV VIGI
Year_1 20% 12%
Year_3 6% 1%
Year_5 14% 7%

A high score indicates both assets are experiencing similar price trends relative to their recent history, suggesting comparable market enthusiasm or concern.

geo
A+

geo

Evaluates the geographical similarity of the assets based on country, currency, and exchange.

  • Currency: USD vs USD
  • Exchange: BTS vs NGM

A high score indicates that both assets operate in similar geographical markets, facing comparable economic conditions, regulations, and market dynamics.

dividend
A+

dividend

Compares dividend policies, showing similarity in shareholder return strategies and income potential for investors.

  • ESGV Dividend Yield: 1%
  • VIGI Dividend Yield: 2%

A high score indicates similar approaches to returning capital to shareholders, suggesting comparable appeal to income-focused investors.

Select Mutual Comparables:

P/E Ratio
20.60
Annual Dividend Rate
1.87%
Beta
0.77
50-Day Moving Average
$82.09
Price vs. 50-Day MA
3.57%
200-Day Moving Average
$83.56
Price vs. 200-Day MA
1.75%
1 Year Fund Flow
$1,138M (16% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
$3,076M (44% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$4,879M (69% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings
34%
% in Top 15 Holdings
43%
% in Top 50 Holdings
74%
ESG Score
7.6700
ESG Peer %
85.04
ESG Global %
91.73
Carbon Intensity
71
ESG Exclusion %
8.64
Sustainable Impact %
11.48
Toggle between similar ETFs and stocks for comparison.

Loading comparable ETFs ...

iShares MSCI USA ESG Select ETF

SUSA - PCX
A+
$122.19 +1.76 (1.46%)
Large Cap Growth Equities
Equity
AUM: $3,566M
Expense Ratio: 0.25% (Low)
Volume: 150.6K (Moderate)
Issuer: BlackRock, Inc.
Holdings: 176
Inception: 2005-01-24 (20 years)
Neutral Momentum
Medium AUM
Very High Concentration
Moderate Volatility

SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 Growth ETF

SPYG - PCX
A+
$87.59 +1.56 (1.81%)
Large Cap Growth Equities
Equity
AUM: $27,961M
Expense Ratio: 0.04% (Very Low)
Volume: 2.3M (High)
Issuer: State Street
Holdings: 232
Inception: 2000-09-25 (24 years)
Neutral Momentum
Large AUM
Low Concentration
Moderate Volatility

Nuveen ESG Large-Cap Growth ETF

NULG - BTS
A+
$83.54 +1.10 (1.33%)
Large Cap Growth Equities
Equity
AUM: $1,444M
Expense Ratio: 0.26% (Low)
Volume: 84.2K (Low)
Issuer: TIAA Board of Governors
Holdings: 63
Inception: 2016-12-13 (8 years)
Weak Momentum
Medium AUM
Moderate Concentration
Moderate Volatility

Vanguard International Dividend Appreciation Index Fund ETF Shares

VIGI - NGM
A
$85.02 +1.16 (1.38%)
Foreign Large Cap Equities
Equity
AUM: $7,039M
Expense Ratio: 0.10% (Low)
Volume: 96.5K (Low)
Issuer: Vanguard
Holdings: 338
Inception: 2016-02-25 (9 years)
Neutral Momentum
Medium AUM
Very High Concentration
Low Volatility