Skip to Content

Find Comparable ETFs for Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETF

Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETF

FDIS - PCX
ETF Category
Consumer Discretionary Equities
Asset Class
Equity
AUM
$1,666M
Expense Ratio
0.08% (Very Low)
Trading Volume
15.2K (Low)
Issuer
Fidelity
Number of Holdings
272
Inception Date
2013-10-21 (11 years)
Momentum
Very Weak Weak Very Strong
AUM
Micro Medium Very Large
Concentration
Very Low Very High Very High
Volatility
Very Low Moderate Very High
Overview
Momentum
Concentration
ESG
P/E Ratio
20.76
Annual Dividend Rate
0.78%
Beta
1.25
50-Day Moving Average
$98.17
Price vs. 50-Day MA
-8.48%
200-Day Moving Average
$88.94
Price vs. 200-Day MA
1.02%
1 Year Fund Flow
$219M (13% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
$29M (2% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$375M (23% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings (Market Cap Weighted)
56.46%
% in Top 15 Holdings (Market Cap Weighted)
62.39%
% in Top 50 Holdings (Market Cap Weighted)
79.93%
ESG Score
6.1200
ESG Peer %
44.39
ESG Global %
40.14
Carbon Intensity (Tons CO2e/$M Sales)
53
ESG Exclusion %
26.27
Sustainable Impact %
1.71

VanEck Retail ETF

RTH - NGM
View RTH's Comps
A+
TaxGhost's "TG Grade" is calculated from 100+ datapoints including fundamental metrics, factors, country, correlation, sub-sector, and more.
Consumer Discretionary Equities
Equity
AUM: $213M
Expense Ratio: 0.35% (Very Low)
Volume: 2.0K (Very Low)
Issuer: VanEck
Holdings: 26
Inception: 2011-12-20 (13 years)
Neutral Momentum
Small AUM
High Concentration
Low Volatility
Compare
Overview
Momentum
Concent.
ESG

The Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETF (FDIS) includes a range of consumer discretionary stocks, similar to RTH, but with a broader focus across the sector.

correlation
A+

correlation

Measures how closely the two assets' prices move together over time. A high correlation suggests similar market reactions and investor sentiment.

Pearson Correlation: 73%

R-squared: 53%

This indicates a strong positive relationship between the price movements of these assets.

network
A+

network

Evaluates the overlap in business networks, partnerships, and industry relationships, indicating similarity in market positioning and competitive landscape.

  • Common comparables: 3
  • FDIS in RTH's comparables: Yes
  • RTH in FDIS's comparables: No

A high score suggests the assets are often compared to each other and share many industry peers, indicating similar competitive environments and market perceptions.

valuation
A+

valuation

Compares valuation metrics to assess if the assets are valued similarly by the market, indicating comparable investor expectations and perceived growth potential.

  • P/E Ratio: 20.76 vs 23.68

A high score indicates that the market values these assets similarly relative to their financials, suggesting comparable growth expectations and risk profiles.

volatility
A-

volatility

Compares price volatility and risk profiles, indicating similarity in market behavior, risk, and potential for price swings.

  • FDIS Beta: 1.25 (High)
  • RTH Beta: 0.88 (Average)
  • FDIS 200-day Volatility: 17.08%
  • RTH 200-day Volatility: 11.65%

A high score suggests both assets have similar sensitivity to market movements, implying comparable risk levels and potential for both gains and losses.

momentum
A+

momentum

Compares recent price momentum, showing similarity in short-term market performance and investor sentiment.

  • FDIS Price vs 200-day MA: 101%
  • RTH Price vs 200-day MA: 106%

Performance Comparison:

Period FDIS RTH
Year_1 7% 15%
Year_3 0% 6%
Year_5 12% 14%

A high score indicates both assets are experiencing similar price trends relative to their recent history, suggesting comparable market enthusiasm or concern.

geo
A+

geo

Evaluates the geographical similarity of the assets based on country, currency, and exchange.

  • Currency: USD vs USD
  • Exchange: PCX vs NGM

A high score indicates that both assets operate in similar geographical markets, facing comparable economic conditions, regulations, and market dynamics.

sector
A+

sector

Compares the sector, industry, and other classifications of both assets.

  • ETF Category: Consumer Discretionary Equities vs Consumer Discretionary Equities

A high score indicates that the assets operate in similar business areas, facing comparable market conditions, regulatory environments, and industry trends.

Partial matches are considered for more nuanced comparisons, allowing for a higher score even when classifications are not identical but closely related.

dividend
A+

dividend

Compares dividend policies, showing similarity in shareholder return strategies and income potential for investors.

  • FDIS Dividend Yield: 1%
  • RTH Dividend Yield: 1%

A high score indicates similar approaches to returning capital to shareholders, suggesting comparable appeal to income-focused investors.

Select Mutual Comparables:

P/E Ratio
23.68
Annual Dividend Rate
0.99%
Beta
0.88
50-Day Moving Average
$233.33
Price vs. 50-Day MA
-0.69%
200-Day Moving Average
$218.05
Price vs. 200-Day MA
6.27%
1 Year Fund Flow
$29M (14% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
-$89M (-42% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$56M (26% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings
73%
% in Top 15 Holdings
87%
% in Top 50 Holdings
100%
ESG Score
6.6400
ESG Peer %
67.86
ESG Global %
54.25
Carbon Intensity
20
ESG Exclusion %
20.58
Sustainable Impact %
0.29

SPDR S&P Retail ETF

XRT - PCX
View XRT's Comps
A+
TaxGhost's "TG Grade" is calculated from 100+ datapoints including fundamental metrics, factors, country, correlation, sub-sector, and more.
Consumer Discretionary Equities
Equity
AUM: $404M
Expense Ratio: 0.35% (Low)
Volume: 5.7M (High)
Issuer: State Street
Holdings: 78
Inception: 2006-06-19 (18 years)
Weak Momentum
Small AUM
Low Concentration
High Volatility
Compare
Overview
Momentum
Concent.
ESG

correlation
A+

correlation

Measures how closely the two assets' prices move together over time. A high correlation suggests similar market reactions and investor sentiment.

Pearson Correlation: 70%

R-squared: 49%

This indicates a moderate positive relationship between the price movements of these assets.

network
A+

network

Evaluates the overlap in business networks, partnerships, and industry relationships, indicating similarity in market positioning and competitive landscape.

  • Common comparables: 3
  • FDIS in XRT's comparables: Yes
  • XRT in FDIS's comparables: No

A high score suggests the assets are often compared to each other and share many industry peers, indicating similar competitive environments and market perceptions.

valuation
A+

valuation

Compares valuation metrics to assess if the assets are valued similarly by the market, indicating comparable investor expectations and perceived growth potential.

  • P/E Ratio: 20.76 vs 10.87

A high score indicates that the market values these assets similarly relative to their financials, suggesting comparable growth expectations and risk profiles.

volatility
A

volatility

Compares price volatility and risk profiles, indicating similarity in market behavior, risk, and potential for price swings.

  • FDIS Beta: 1.25 (High)
  • XRT Beta: 1.31 (High)
  • FDIS 200-day Volatility: 17.08%
  • XRT 200-day Volatility: 21.10%

A high score suggests both assets have similar sensitivity to market movements, implying comparable risk levels and potential for both gains and losses.

momentum
A+

momentum

Compares recent price momentum, showing similarity in short-term market performance and investor sentiment.

  • FDIS Price vs 200-day MA: 101%
  • XRT Price vs 200-day MA: 92%

Performance Comparison:

Period FDIS XRT
Year_1 7% 12%
Year_3 0% -6%
Year_5 12% 14%

A high score indicates both assets are experiencing similar price trends relative to their recent history, suggesting comparable market enthusiasm or concern.

geo
A+

geo

Evaluates the geographical similarity of the assets based on country, currency, and exchange.

  • Currency: USD vs USD
  • Exchange: PCX vs PCX

A high score indicates that both assets operate in similar geographical markets, facing comparable economic conditions, regulations, and market dynamics.

sector
A+

sector

Compares the sector, industry, and other classifications of both assets.

  • ETF Category: Consumer Discretionary Equities vs Consumer Discretionary Equities

A high score indicates that the assets operate in similar business areas, facing comparable market conditions, regulatory environments, and industry trends.

Partial matches are considered for more nuanced comparisons, allowing for a higher score even when classifications are not identical but closely related.

dividend
A+

dividend

Compares dividend policies, showing similarity in shareholder return strategies and income potential for investors.

  • FDIS Dividend Yield: 1%
  • XRT Dividend Yield: 1%

A high score indicates similar approaches to returning capital to shareholders, suggesting comparable appeal to income-focused investors.

Select Mutual Comparables:

P/E Ratio
10.87
Annual Dividend Rate
1.33%
Beta
1.31
50-Day Moving Average
$78.72
Price vs. 50-Day MA
-9.30%
200-Day Moving Average
$77.32
Price vs. 200-Day MA
-7.66%
1 Year Fund Flow
-$138M (-34% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
-$548M (-136% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$10M (2% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings
16%
% in Top 15 Holdings
24%
% in Top 50 Holdings
72%
ESG Score
6.7800
ESG Peer %
71.43
ESG Global %
60.68
Carbon Intensity
20
ESG Exclusion %
2.80
Sustainable Impact %
1.53

Fidelity MSCI Consumer Staples Index ETF

FSTA - PCX
View FSTA's Comps
A-
TaxGhost's "TG Grade" is calculated from 100+ datapoints including fundamental metrics, factors, country, correlation, sub-sector, and more.
Consumer Staples Equities
Equity
AUM: $1,101M
Expense Ratio: 0.08% (Very Low)
Volume: 99.8K (Low)
Issuer: Fidelity
Holdings: 105
Inception: 2013-10-21 (11 years)
Neutral Momentum
Medium AUM
Very High Concentration
Moderate Volatility
Compare
Overview
Momentum
Concent.
ESG

The Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETF provides exposure to consumer-related stocks, allowing for a comparison in sector focus, albeit in a discretionary context.

correlation
B

correlation

Measures how closely the two assets' prices move together over time. A high correlation suggests similar market reactions and investor sentiment.

Pearson Correlation: 25%

R-squared: 6%

This indicates a negligible relationship between the price movements of these assets.

network
A

network

Evaluates the overlap in business networks, partnerships, and industry relationships, indicating similarity in market positioning and competitive landscape.

  • Common comparables: 0
  • FDIS in FSTA's comparables: Yes
  • FSTA in FDIS's comparables: No

A high score suggests the assets are often compared to each other and share many industry peers, indicating similar competitive environments and market perceptions.

valuation
A+

valuation

Compares valuation metrics to assess if the assets are valued similarly by the market, indicating comparable investor expectations and perceived growth potential.

  • P/E Ratio: 20.76 vs 23.70

A high score indicates that the market values these assets similarly relative to their financials, suggesting comparable growth expectations and risk profiles.

volatility
A-

volatility

Compares price volatility and risk profiles, indicating similarity in market behavior, risk, and potential for price swings.

  • FDIS Beta: 1.25 (High)
  • FSTA Beta: 0.60 (Low)
  • FDIS 200-day Volatility: 17.08%
  • FSTA 200-day Volatility: 9.47%

A high score suggests both assets have similar sensitivity to market movements, implying comparable risk levels and potential for both gains and losses.

momentum
A+

momentum

Compares recent price momentum, showing similarity in short-term market performance and investor sentiment.

  • FDIS Price vs 200-day MA: 101%
  • FSTA Price vs 200-day MA: 104%

Performance Comparison:

Period FDIS FSTA
Year_1 7% 9%
Year_3 0% 7%
Year_5 12% 9%

A high score indicates both assets are experiencing similar price trends relative to their recent history, suggesting comparable market enthusiasm or concern.

geo
A+

geo

Evaluates the geographical similarity of the assets based on country, currency, and exchange.

  • Currency: USD vs USD
  • Exchange: PCX vs PCX

A high score indicates that both assets operate in similar geographical markets, facing comparable economic conditions, regulations, and market dynamics.

sector
A

sector

Compares the sector, industry, and other classifications of both assets.

  • ETF Category: Consumer Discretionary Equities vs Consumer Staples Equities

A high score indicates that the assets operate in similar business areas, facing comparable market conditions, regulatory environments, and industry trends.

Partial matches are considered for more nuanced comparisons, allowing for a higher score even when classifications are not identical but closely related.

dividend
A+

dividend

Compares dividend policies, showing similarity in shareholder return strategies and income potential for investors.

  • FDIS Dividend Yield: 1%
  • FSTA Dividend Yield: 2%

A high score indicates similar approaches to returning capital to shareholders, suggesting comparable appeal to income-focused investors.

Select Mutual Comparables:

P/E Ratio
23.70
Annual Dividend Rate
2.50%
Beta
0.60
50-Day Moving Average
$50.39
Price vs. 50-Day MA
3.20%
200-Day Moving Average
$49.85
Price vs. 200-Day MA
4.31%
1 Year Fund Flow
-$175M (-16% of AUM)
3 Year Fund Flow
$180M (16% of AUM)
5 Year Fund Flow
$295M (27% of AUM)
% in Top 10 Holdings
62%
% in Top 15 Holdings
70%
% in Top 50 Holdings
93%
ESG Score
6.7300
ESG Peer %
52.00
ESG Global %
58.49
Carbon Intensity
44
ESG Exclusion %
11.22
Sustainable Impact %
4.67
Toggle between similar ETFs and stocks for comparison.

Loading comparable ETFs ...

VanEck Retail ETF

RTH - NGM
A+
$231.72 +1.81 (0.79%)
Consumer Discretionary Equities
Equity
AUM: $213M
Expense Ratio: 0.35% (Very Low)
Volume: 2.0K (Very Low)
Issuer: VanEck
Holdings: 26
Inception: 2011-12-20 (13 years)
Neutral Momentum
Small AUM
High Concentration
Low Volatility

SPDR S&P Retail ETF

XRT - PCX
A+
$71.40 +0.58 (0.82%)
Consumer Discretionary Equities
Equity
AUM: $404M
Expense Ratio: 0.35% (Low)
Volume: 5.7M (High)
Issuer: State Street
Holdings: 78
Inception: 2006-06-19 (18 years)
Weak Momentum
Small AUM
Low Concentration
High Volatility

Fidelity MSCI Consumer Staples Index ETF

FSTA - PCX
A-
$52.00 +0.18 (0.35%)
Consumer Staples Equities
Equity
AUM: $1,101M
Expense Ratio: 0.08% (Very Low)
Volume: 99.8K (Low)
Issuer: Fidelity
Holdings: 105
Inception: 2013-10-21 (11 years)
Neutral Momentum
Medium AUM
Very High Concentration
Moderate Volatility